Blue Moon Ice Cream is a Midwestern classic that originated in Milwaukee in the 1950s. This mysterious blue-hued treat boasts dominant flavors of raspberry, lemon, and vanilla. Some say it tastes like Fruity Pebbles cereal, and it’s sometimes called Smurf Ice Cream.

FULL RECIPE:

Ingredients

1½ cups milk (dairy or plant-based)
⅓ cup heavy cream
2 tablespoons instant vanilla pudding mix
1 teaspoon raspberry extract
½ teaspoon lemon extract
15 drops blue food coloring

Directions

In a pint container, combine milk, vanilla pudding mix, heavy cream, raspberry extract, lemon extract, and blue food coloring. Whisk to combine.
Cover the pint and freeze for 24 hours.
After freezing, use your Ninja Creami machine on the “Ice Cream” setting.
Remove the pint and check the texture. If it’s a bit chalky or not as creamy as desired, make a hole in the center of the ice cream and add a tablespoon of water or milk. Then, use the “re-spin” function. Repeat until the texture is creamy.
Serve with toppings like sprinkles, Fruity Pebbles cereal, or cherries, if desired.

Nutrition Facts

Calories: ~180 kcal
Total Fat: 10g
- Saturated Fat: 6g
Cholesterol: 35mg
Sodium: 60mg
Total Carbohydrates: 18g
- Sugars: 15g
Protein: 3g
Calcium: ~10% DV

The History of Blue Moon Ice Cream

Blue Moon Ice Cream is a beloved treat that has intrigued people for decades. This mysterious, bright blue ice cream is believed to have originated in the Midwest, particularly in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, during the 1950s. While its exact origins remain unclear, many credit Bill Sidon, a flavor chemist, with its creation. The recipe has been closely guarded, and different ice cream brands have attempted to replicate its unique taste. Unlike traditional flavors like vanilla or chocolate, Blue Moon Ice Cream is known for its distinctive, fruity, and slightly citrusy taste. Many describe it as reminiscent of Fruity Pebbles cereal, while others compare it to marshmallows or cotton candy. Despite its popularity in the Midwest, it is rarely found in other parts of the United States, making it a regional specialty.

The Mystery Behind Its Flavor

One of the most intriguing aspects of Blue Moon Ice Cream is its flavor. Unlike other well-known flavors that are easy to identify, Blue Moon has an almost indescribable taste. It is a blend of sweet, fruity, and slightly tangy notes, often attributed to raspberry and lemon extracts. However, some versions may include almond or vanilla flavors to enhance the overall profile. The mystery surrounding Blue Moon’s flavor has led to countless debates. Some believe it tastes like childhood nostalgia, while others say it has a bubblegum-like essence. This enigmatic quality has only added to the ice cream’s charm, making it a favorite among those who grew up enjoying it.

Why Blue Moon Ice Cream is So Popular

Blue Moon Ice Cream is more than just a dessert it’s a nostalgic experience. For many Midwesterners, it brings back childhood memories of visiting local ice cream parlors and enjoying a scoop on a warm summer day. The vibrant blue color also adds to its appeal, making it stand out among other flavors. The exclusivity of Blue Moon also plays a role in its popularity. Because it is primarily available in the Midwest, those who move away from the region often seek ways to recreate it at home. Homemade recipes have become increasingly popular, allowing fans to enjoy this classic treat no matter where they are.

Tips for Making the Perfect Blue Moon Ice Cream

Creating Blue Moon Ice Cream at home is a fun and rewarding experience. To achieve the best results, consider the following tips:

Use High-Quality Ingredients: The key to a creamy and flavorful ice cream is using high-quality dairy and extracts. Opt for full-fat milk and cream to achieve a rich texture.
Experiment with Flavors: Since the exact Blue Moon recipe remains a mystery, don’t be afraid to experiment. Some people add a hint of almond or vanilla extract for extra depth.
Get the Right Color: Blue Moon Ice Cream is known for its signature blue color. If you want the perfect shade, use a few drops of blue food coloring.
Use an Ice Cream Machine or Ninja Creami: To achieve a smooth and creamy consistency, use an ice cream machine. The Ninja Creami is also a great tool for making ice cream at home.

Pairing Blue Moon Ice Cream with Other Desserts

Blue Moon Ice Cream pairs well with a variety of desserts. Its fruity and creamy taste makes it a versatile treat that complements many flavors. Some great pairing ideas include:

Waffles or Pancakes: Add a scoop of Blue Moon Ice Cream on top of freshly made waffles or pancakes for a fun breakfast treat.
Sugar Cones or Waffle Cones: The crunchiness of a cone enhances the creamy texture of the ice cream.
Brownies: The richness of chocolate brownies pairs beautifully with the fruity notes of Blue Moon Ice Cream.
Milkshakes: Blend Blue Moon Ice Cream with a bit of milk to create a refreshing and nostalgic milkshake.

Why You Should Try Making Blue Moon Ice Cream at Home

While Blue Moon Ice Cream is a specialty in the Midwest, making it at home allows people from all over to enjoy this nostalgic treat. There are many benefits to homemade ice cream:

Customization: You can control the ingredients and adjust the flavors to suit your preference.
No Artificial Additives: Store-bought ice creams often contain preservatives and artificial ingredients. Homemade ice cream ensures a cleaner, more natural treat.
Fun for the Whole Family: Making ice cream is an enjoyable activity for kids and adults alike. It’s a great way to involve family members in the kitchen.

Conclusion

Blue Moon Ice Cream is a unique and nostalgic dessert that holds a special place in the hearts of Midwesterners. Its mysterious flavor, bright blue color, and regional exclusivity make it a one-of-a-kind treat. While its origins remain somewhat of a mystery, one thing is certain Blue Moon Ice Cream continues to captivate those who try it. Whether you grew up eating Blue Moon or are discovering it for the first time, making it at home is a fun and rewarding experience. By experimenting with flavors and ingredients, you can recreate this iconic treat and enjoy a taste of the Midwest no matter where you live.

Pin1

1 Shares